There was an intense and decentralized effort by numerous members of the BCH community to defend against the threatened re-org attacks by CSW.
As far as I could tell the group of miners referred too loosely as the attacker aka CSW were the majority BCH miners. The attacker it seems was colluding with some exchanges to have the ABC rule set declared as the official BCH ruleset.
No one has all the information but everyone is trying to work together to make the best decisions for bitcoin.
If this was true and people realized they did not have perfect information why were they ignoring my advice, and secondly how can they conclude forcing a split in the network is good for bitcoin?
I think the situation was handled well. Everyone I interacted with was working hard for the best interests of bitcoin.
It went anything but well, ABC got what they want, I can only make sense of that sentence above when I change "best interests of bitcoin" to "best interests of ABC"
We are destined to relearn how bitcoin works, it's not about the code, in its simplicity it is secured by economic incentives.
Bitcoin is a network of people who share a common belief that bitcoin is money. Money is a fictitious construct, at the core, it's a network of trust, a network of people who believe what you believe.
Anyone who believes bitcoin has value is part of the network, Ignoring the incentives has consequences. I think there is a biblical analogy suited for this moment. It's called The Great Flood.
Developers have moved so far from the fundamental understanding that keeps bitcoin working that they've undermined the only thing that makes it work, the people who believe it has future value as money.
Bitcoin is not code it's a set of rules that make up a protocol, and when you follow those rules, you get to write to an immutable ledger. The fact it runs on a computer makes it more efficient.
I think Bitcoin handled the situation even though the developers in control of changing the rules were ignoring the network of people who believe what I believe.