Christoph Bergmann
Active Member
SV asked for a delay of the fork, ABC rejected BIP135 too.Better ways of deploying change have been proposed, no compromise from SV.
That's why I said, out of my head and possibly wrong. Disappointing to hear that it has nothing to do with UTXO commitments. I had an interview with Tomas, in which he told me he hopes that the protocol changes for UTXO commitments go in the fork for Nov ...p.s. @Christoph Bergmann : I don't think a particular method for UTXO commitment is the primary driver for ABC to push for Merklix. You should do some more investigation - I would suggest you try to get @deadalnix to sit down with you for an in-depth interview to hash out the questions you have around Merklix + their entire strategy. I hope he would be willing to give you 1 or 2 hours.
My feeling - I've also not talked this through but it's from what I've read up to now - is that he wanted it more for 2 reasons:
a) data structures efficiency
b) more options for fraud proofs
The first one might make sense to me if demonstrated that at very large scale, this structure would have great benefits over current Merkle tree.
The second one I'm not so sure we need, with the other suggestions already available around fraud proofs that don't depend on changes to the data structure.
But I may be out of the loop on the UTXO commitment developments. If someone can confirm whether that's part of the reason for introduction of Merklix, that would be appreciated.
Anyway ... I think you don't fully understand what I wrote ... I don't know if I continue to be so much interested in BCH after the Nov fork. For sure I will stop fighting the "bcash bcash centralized shitcoin" trolls, and for sure I will have less love for it.
Like at least half of the German BCH community attending my blog and some other social media sources I frequent. You will lose support for gaining NOTHING, and if there is one thing BCH needs more than everything else, it is SUPPORT. It is already very low ... I think you still do not realize all this ...