The most meaningful figures are those of the Diamond Princess. Zero victims under 70 years.
7 victims of those 288 positive tested passengers over 70 years.
I think you are both right in some way. It is neither an overreaction nor an underreaction. It is wrong reaction. South Korea alone seems to be responding adequately, with full transparency and full reaction with technical means that made it possible to prevent a lockdown of the economy.
China had an underreaction when they covered up information and eliminated Kassandra. Classic state terror by anonymous criminal politicians.
Europe has an underreaction in the delivery of ventilators and intensive care units. This inevitably leads to chaos and panic, which they want to prevent with a lockdown of the economy, which is an overreaction that I believe leads to even more chaos, panic and victims.
And the society/swarm around Trump? Probably the dumbest of all possible democratic societies.
US airlines already need 50 billion Dollars. Imagine how much the whole econmy will need to survive.
At the moment I am having the greatest difficulty imagining a scenario how the demise of civilization can be averted again. If the numbers in Italy do not indicate a turnaround in the next few days, then it looks like Game Over.
My solution would be 'learn from South Korea' and try to solve the problem without a lockdown of the economy.
@lunar's full transparency instead of ancap, privacy and anonymity. No lockdown, but full concentration in the provision of intensive care beds and temporary care staff. Social distance can be maintained without a lockdown.
A well-known virologist in Switzerland claims that we have enough money to survive a three-month lockdown.
They have no idea about the economy and society, historical breakdowns etc.
But politicians now seem to be listening to such experts. We will have a lockdown until 19th april, they declared.