### VOTING IS CLOSED for BUIPs 2, 4, 5, 10 & 13 ###

solex · Jan 28, 2016

Membership vote on BU Improvement Processes

The technical BUIPS listed below are open for vote.

Please reply to this thread.

Votes are for/against.
Votes can be in the same message e.g. "for x,y,z" or "against a,b,c" where x,y,z etc are BUIP numbers.

BUIP004 has 4 sub-options A1, A2, B, C please mention which is preferred.

BUIP013 has 2 sub-options A, B please mention which is preferred.

Technical BUIP List

BUIP002: Multi-BIP Scaling Enabler
@solex

BUIP004: RBF/double spending support
@Inca

BUIP005: Settings information via coinbase-txn & user-agent
@solex

BUIP010 Xtreme Thinblocks
@Peter Tschipper

BUIP013: Upgrade alert system so that the Bitcoin Unlimited project can send message alerts to nodes
@bitcartel
Votes need to be signed.

Please get involved. Bitcoin Unlimited is the start of a new paradigm where the membership decides which software changes get made to the client.
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
15TiujYmnHa33fjEnasBBm1eWcGx9YEXPL
IEIBY9jJS8ek3aU04kopEvbFHwn8h1Do6v7ExVsb49EiWE4Q6oX+B5NarFISrHQc6a36kt2GFo3W0MIU9UsJOqY=

solex · Jan 28, 2016

FOR BUIP002
FOR BUIP004 A1
FOR BUIP005
FOR BUIP010
FOR BUIP013 A
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
15TiujYmnHa33fjEnasBBm1eWcGx9YEXPL
IMPjtXuhLUDzkfOyQKt5mSC/q/+2C26Qshg3AEGNthwXUZbTlLNNXXyDDH//tthxii+XSxvvQZFuR+P/Feks4cM=

Peter R · Jan 28, 2016

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Peter R votes for:
BUIP004(A1)
BUIP005
BUIP010
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
1BWZe6XkGLcf6DWC3TFXiEtZmcyAoNq5BW
IKdcNuTfTMx8KMSGtTOq9vUXTmcWiMopTi08KCwtBQVItjsazX8cqdAlykS3tyfn+zidMmpHnRi4iE95/PWTUmM=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----

I'm not opposed to either 002 or 013 but I don't feel I've paid enough attention to either to cast a vote at this time.

Roy Badami · Jan 28, 2016

FOR BUIP002,BUIP005,BUIP010
FOR BUIP004 A1
AGAINST BUIP013
-----------------BTC-Address-----------------
1GfHipP1Wi9kqQwSQiWneusNwTtCiRKP8W
------------------signature----------------------
H7JTxDjl22zJfvj0WKoZVUUFmTeCnrhrjuXLyhpEUlU6EZa3ZgVWZJWBAX9VIqTKOTa8uR7h5bBEeNtnI2Vzfa4=

Peter Tschipper · Jan 28, 2016

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
FOR BUIP002, BUIP005 , BUIP010
FOR BUIP004 A1
FOR BUIP013 A
-----BEGIN BITCOIN ADDRESS----
1AmdP3nFWSJhkzszXHZNQiJLx7eUGRbzvs
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
ILuwFWdR6XSyO0poAfq4a1DyE+LNHnCstB7bX1FzAtulZPj5bxsszi+QAgRHqklou2z66cQsqXeEozdWwKKWMjQ=

TrevinHofmann · Jan 28, 2016

lunar · Jan 28, 2016

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
FOR BUIP002
FOR BUIP004 A1
FOR BUIP005
FOR BUIP010
FOR BUIP013 A
-----BEGIN BITCOIN ADDRESS----
1BpYYT2HQzQdz5CFPM1nehCZd1xWPtNbma
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
IEcaGo5xdLKb4sKeG3rgqmy9Zouk73SaLlonKnlAgZNTFK0aDFG98oSfYNszipGxAd/pwhZcBP9E14onzYyyJ9Q=

kostialevin · Jan 29, 2016

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
FOR BUIP002
FOR BUIP004 A1
AGAINST BUIP005
FOR BUIP010
FOR BUIP013 B
-----BTC ADDRESS----------------------
1BTXKkt2TmkPEDmn6EBhh8t8r9cPbKwbBF
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE------------------
G+jPxC2MhBOvdI+xHmoPOgpnuBUFkAf7tHvzphk7+IsBCQUfvsG2UElow13wEY43B0AozkSa22sodpQWQQHtiKI=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-------

Lee Adams · Jan 29, 2016

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
FOR BUIP002

ABSTAIN BUIP004

AGAINST BUIP005

FOR BUIP010

FOR BUIP013 B

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
Address: 1ruQ2wceuMt83aXQsERyWGxQawHqXERSd

H2SsOiCNwq1y//K7oZ0Viq6j7/vX1z8h57uErN4IuSDDLXpE+fkGC4bW5wpLn2VbemohAyJuPI9pMuxJiNr+gqk=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----

YarkoL · Jan 29, 2016

FOR BUIP002,
FOR BUIP004 C,
FOR BUIP005,
FOR BUIP010,
FOR BUIP013 A

bitcoin-cli signmessage 1QJRHKrZs9V6XVeM9hAaB6jv9JYFvLLSox 'FOR BUIP002, FOR BUIP004 C, FOR BUIP005, FOR BUIP010, FOR BUIP013 A'
H6mJFmLTRRgMb2C7cqbwM7grz3rOk/QZGm0M/mwRai2kXp/PAvs6jxpo1XPR2obRTYJIxNeDSO/tZfjl2OuQHxA=

sickpig · Jan 29, 2016

vote:

FOR BUIP002,BUIP005,BUIP010,BUIP004 A1

address:

1LwvkQTWmotqTosgBcK8kFPCKzW2BPiE1G

signature:

H2+NIiw9UN4WM5THnzMsIxcSKxhGlj+nkOjElvsXbkUOdthXbdAScZeAZmFjxXvOTTKEM/EqT0gm98uqx3PoqlY=

awemany · Jan 29, 2016

Awemany votes on Bitcoin Unlimited BUIPs on Friday, Jan 29th 2016,
on the web forum bitco.in/forum:

BUIP002: FOR
BUIP004: FOR A1
BUIP005: I abstain
BUIP010: FOR
BUIP013: I abstain

Signature:
H508+1KhP4b/vPrOPSMASWRdn5Wwnkqli1x4Fhlm1dDaWptKUNHQhK98cyAuLj97bBYG68x8ECJApXfOr0Jdahs=

My BTC address:
1BCnpopAZ4xFSxdX8NvVqUaSvsPffQhNRd

theZerg · Jan 29, 2016

thezerg votes on Bitcoin Unlimited BUIPs on Friday, Jan 29th 2016,
on the web forum bitco.in/forum:

BUIP002: FOR
BUIP004: FOR A1
BUIP005: FOR
BUIP010: FOR
BUIP013: Prefer A, vote for B
END
1zerg12nRXZ41Pw4tfCTqgtdiJx6D1We3
HB38Zuj9pDXsRirGNqHXENFMa6SZ3nDbdrhRKPMemBqYdA7DAlmqOs70DKNvKumHw6HPkoE0hOUK5eCGKovQE7Q=

VeritasSapere · Jan 29, 2016

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
FOR BUIP002
FOR BUIP004 A1
FOR BUIP005
ABSTAIN BUIP010
FOR BUIP013 A
-----BTC ADDRESS----------------------
1PQ1BB819gxUbDZX3aReBXx4r7zGo67jXi
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE------------------
IG/UiALbn14Npr//tbpAm88HquihjYm/JF8qWRONmkY5GkTCTnqmDTQYpi79xpPVk6cyINbOyOa3kGqZQ6qLyJU=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-------

bitcartel · Jan 29, 2016

FOR BUIP002
FOR BUIP004 A1
FOR BUIP005
FOR BUIP010
FOR BUIP013 A
-----BTC ADDRESS----------------------
16tA8bcwFve5FDpTaNTPRFg5Jn5GLBpMrL
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE------------------
H5I1ixNyCT7t58Ye9q1WLNuTkwUoMk/Eyspo0yatFCOvNZR5FZ4mCVhB0DBjpdQpYaEhN8+al3kPfhIyLM6NWPw=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-------

Inca · Jan 29, 2016

FOR BUIP002
FOR BUIP004 A1
FOR BUIP005
FOR BUIP010
FOR BUIP013 A

Msg: 'inca'
Address: '1AxZbSghNyFZJ8RD4G4fuTENEXZWJwPmJM'
Public key: '
043756e745961a67eff703ecd48fdf46e52f1a996aa604e4915261e1810f3f51ca2d21e0bb1a1c512883e3bc8b73e619c2e79f84d70cc9df5833c91cf7dcc8316d'
Sig: 'HOYN0sTf0A0K6r1Bxia3PVZR5ve99hUISnWgjUHdOWIdbev0O+7BVCRbufAdKGC9WVHVFe2VF45d5ezpoC800YU='

freetrader · Jan 30, 2016

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Comment: Signed by Bitcoin Armory v0.93.2

FOR BUIP002

FOR BUIP004 A1

FOR BUIP005

FOR BUIP010

FOR BUIP013 A

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----

HMxnjlKf4XF2AUXXEtAk+qZlPfvsa7kuOkxCVcxrIQPndDo3EeHXeoj7CaU9I0Ug
6HSc1o/iuzN+xB9tNLYA+9Y=
=6Yjc
-----END BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----

cypherdoc · Jan 30, 2016

solex · Jan 30, 2016

Voting is closed. Posting the results here after verification:

EDIT: The votes are as follows

BUIP002 17/0 passed
BUIP004 17/0 passed with A1=15 & C=2, so A1 is passed
BUIP005 15/2 passed
BUIP010 17/0 passed
BUIP013 13/2 passed with A=10 & B=3, so neither have the minimum so the Developer may proceed with what is common between A & B

Note: 43 members, 25% turnout is 11 where >=75% for/against is also required.

### VOTING IS CLOSED for BUIPs 2, 4, 5, 10 & 13 ###

Moderator

Moderator

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Active Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Member

Member

Active Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Moderator

Active Member

Member

Moderator

Moderator

Well-Known Member

Moderator