### VOTING IS CLOSED for BUIPs 2, 4, 5, 10 & 13 ###

solex

Moderator
Staff member
Aug 22, 2015
1,558
4,694
Membership vote on BU Improvement Processes

The technical BUIPS listed below are open for vote.

Please reply to this thread.

Votes are for/against.
Votes can be in the same message e.g. "for x,y,z" or "against a,b,c" where x,y,z etc are BUIP numbers.

BUIP004 has 4 sub-options A1, A2, B, C please mention which is preferred.

BUIP013 has 2 sub-options A, B please mention which is preferred.


Technical BUIP List

BUIP002: Multi-BIP Scaling Enabler
@solex

BUIP004: RBF/double spending support
@Inca

BUIP005: Settings information via coinbase-txn & user-agent
@solex


BUIP010 Xtreme Thinblocks
@Peter Tschipper

BUIP013: Upgrade alert system so that the Bitcoin Unlimited project can send message alerts to nodes
@bitcartel
Votes need to be signed.


Please get involved. Bitcoin Unlimited is the start of a new paradigm where the membership decides which software changes get made to the client.
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
15TiujYmnHa33fjEnasBBm1eWcGx9YEXPL
IEIBY9jJS8ek3aU04kopEvbFHwn8h1Do6v7ExVsb49EiWE4Q6oX+B5NarFISrHQc6a36kt2GFo3W0MIU9UsJOqY=
 

solex

Moderator
Staff member
Aug 22, 2015
1,558
4,694
FOR BUIP002
FOR BUIP004 A1
FOR BUIP005
FOR BUIP010
FOR BUIP013 A
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
15TiujYmnHa33fjEnasBBm1eWcGx9YEXPL
IMPjtXuhLUDzkfOyQKt5mSC/q/+2C26Qshg3AEGNthwXUZbTlLNNXXyDDH//tthxii+XSxvvQZFuR+P/Feks4cM=
 
Last edited:

Peter R

Well-Known Member
Aug 28, 2015
1,398
5,595
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Peter R votes for:
BUIP004(A1)
BUIP005
BUIP010
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
1BWZe6XkGLcf6DWC3TFXiEtZmcyAoNq5BW
IKdcNuTfTMx8KMSGtTOq9vUXTmcWiMopTi08KCwtBQVItjsazX8cqdAlykS3tyfn+zidMmpHnRi4iE95/PWTUmM=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----

I'm not opposed to either 002 or 013 but I don't feel I've paid enough attention to either to cast a vote at this time.
 

Roy Badami

Active Member
Dec 27, 2015
140
203
FOR BUIP002,BUIP005,BUIP010
FOR BUIP004 A1
AGAINST BUIP013
-----------------BTC-Address-----------------
1GfHipP1Wi9kqQwSQiWneusNwTtCiRKP8W
------------------signature----------------------
H7JTxDjl22zJfvj0WKoZVUUFmTeCnrhrjuXLyhpEUlU6EZa3ZgVWZJWBAX9VIqTKOTa8uR7h5bBEeNtnI2Vzfa4=
 

Peter Tschipper

Active Member
Jan 8, 2016
254
357
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
FOR BUIP002, BUIP005 , BUIP010
FOR BUIP004 A1
FOR BUIP013 A
-----BEGIN BITCOIN ADDRESS----
1AmdP3nFWSJhkzszXHZNQiJLx7eUGRbzvs
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
ILuwFWdR6XSyO0poAfq4a1DyE+LNHnCstB7bX1FzAtulZPj5bxsszi+QAgRHqklou2z66cQsqXeEozdWwKKWMjQ=
 
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256

FOR BUIP002
FOR BUIP004 C
FOR BUIP005
FOR BUIP010
FOR BUIP013 A
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2

iQEcBAEBCAAGBQJWqretAAoJEHN9+j2LWHieTAcIANn7BahekSYw0vKAZgphltqq
GNyhPQRjL91EgflYZVsgQ+TQRF4Uu4AuDNvsiEczDqH1KMCsQILGQH7lxnrJjzyi
zbm6pX6jeve9hPVMVlne9h4nFwMPXue4msvZ2pgRNc6BKmpuL2QeW6aZZv3SGM5p
UTdIAt1sof3GMn9anBXt35PGVoFwhTt2CvzsEYcZSq2MER5GYYrkvkZQ/HTNJDax
pMTbSO0j1WVd5S6yxgsds5OHbP4i5jbcyXnV2/IUPeIzM/zW+z3N65ArsTR1wLQS
8NOJmE2Ia1bII7T/ZPsRn+UZ0clqxvazILwtRYOQB2tvKMx3d11bVKx3Ec970fg=
=Dpcz
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
 

lunar

Well-Known Member
Aug 28, 2015
1,001
4,290
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
FOR BUIP002
FOR BUIP004 A1
FOR BUIP005
FOR BUIP010
FOR BUIP013 A
-----BEGIN BITCOIN ADDRESS----
1BpYYT2HQzQdz5CFPM1nehCZd1xWPtNbma
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
IEcaGo5xdLKb4sKeG3rgqmy9Zouk73SaLlonKnlAgZNTFK0aDFG98oSfYNszipGxAd/pwhZcBP9E14onzYyyJ9Q=
 

kostialevin

Member
Dec 21, 2015
55
147
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
FOR BUIP002
FOR BUIP004 A1
AGAINST BUIP005
FOR BUIP010
FOR BUIP013 B
-----BTC ADDRESS----------------------
1BTXKkt2TmkPEDmn6EBhh8t8r9cPbKwbBF
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE------------------
G+jPxC2MhBOvdI+xHmoPOgpnuBUFkAf7tHvzphk7+IsBCQUfvsG2UElow13wEY43B0AozkSa22sodpQWQQHtiKI=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-------
 

Lee Adams

Member
Dec 23, 2015
89
74
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
FOR BUIP002

ABSTAIN BUIP004

AGAINST BUIP005

FOR BUIP010

FOR BUIP013 B

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
Address: 1ruQ2wceuMt83aXQsERyWGxQawHqXERSd

H2SsOiCNwq1y//K7oZ0Viq6j7/vX1z8h57uErN4IuSDDLXpE+fkGC4bW5wpLn2VbemohAyJuPI9pMuxJiNr+gqk=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
 

YarkoL

Active Member
Dec 18, 2015
176
258
Tuusula
yarkol.github.io
FOR BUIP002,
FOR BUIP004 C,
FOR BUIP005,
FOR BUIP010,
FOR BUIP013 A

bitcoin-cli signmessage 1QJRHKrZs9V6XVeM9hAaB6jv9JYFvLLSox 'FOR BUIP002, FOR BUIP004 C, FOR BUIP005, FOR BUIP010, FOR BUIP013 A'
H6mJFmLTRRgMb2C7cqbwM7grz3rOk/QZGm0M/mwRai2kXp/PAvs6jxpo1XPR2obRTYJIxNeDSO/tZfjl2OuQHxA=
 

sickpig

Active Member
Aug 28, 2015
926
2,541
vote:

FOR BUIP002,BUIP005,BUIP010,BUIP004 A1

address:

1LwvkQTWmotqTosgBcK8kFPCKzW2BPiE1G

signature:

H2+NIiw9UN4WM5THnzMsIxcSKxhGlj+nkOjElvsXbkUOdthXbdAScZeAZmFjxXvOTTKEM/EqT0gm98uqx3PoqlY=
 

awemany

Well-Known Member
Aug 19, 2015
1,387
5,054
Awemany votes on Bitcoin Unlimited BUIPs on Friday, Jan 29th 2016,
on the web forum bitco.in/forum:

BUIP002: FOR
BUIP004: FOR A1
BUIP005: I abstain
BUIP010: FOR
BUIP013: I abstain

Signature:
H508+1KhP4b/vPrOPSMASWRdn5Wwnkqli1x4Fhlm1dDaWptKUNHQhK98cyAuLj97bBYG68x8ECJApXfOr0Jdahs=

My BTC address:
1BCnpopAZ4xFSxdX8NvVqUaSvsPffQhNRd
 

theZerg

Moderator
Staff member
Aug 28, 2015
1,012
2,327
thezerg votes on Bitcoin Unlimited BUIPs on Friday, Jan 29th 2016,
on the web forum bitco.in/forum:

BUIP002: FOR
BUIP004: FOR A1
BUIP005: FOR
BUIP010: FOR
BUIP013: Prefer A, vote for B
END
1zerg12nRXZ41Pw4tfCTqgtdiJx6D1We3
HB38Zuj9pDXsRirGNqHXENFMa6SZ3nDbdrhRKPMemBqYdA7DAlmqOs70DKNvKumHw6HPkoE0hOUK5eCGKovQE7Q=
 

VeritasSapere

Active Member
Nov 16, 2015
511
1,266
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
FOR BUIP002
FOR BUIP004 A1
FOR BUIP005
ABSTAIN BUIP010
FOR BUIP013 A
-----BTC ADDRESS----------------------
1PQ1BB819gxUbDZX3aReBXx4r7zGo67jXi
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE------------------
IG/UiALbn14Npr//tbpAm88HquihjYm/JF8qWRONmkY5GkTCTnqmDTQYpi79xpPVk6cyINbOyOa3kGqZQ6qLyJU=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-------
 

bitcartel

Member
Nov 19, 2015
95
93
FOR BUIP002
FOR BUIP004 A1
FOR BUIP005
FOR BUIP010
FOR BUIP013 A
-----BTC ADDRESS----------------------
16tA8bcwFve5FDpTaNTPRFg5Jn5GLBpMrL
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE------------------
H5I1ixNyCT7t58Ye9q1WLNuTkwUoMk/Eyspo0yatFCOvNZR5FZ4mCVhB0DBjpdQpYaEhN8+al3kPfhIyLM6NWPw=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-------
 

Inca

Moderator
Staff member
Aug 28, 2015
517
1,679
FOR BUIP002
FOR BUIP004 A1
FOR BUIP005
FOR BUIP010
FOR BUIP013 A

Msg: 'inca'
Address: '1AxZbSghNyFZJ8RD4G4fuTENEXZWJwPmJM'
Public key: '
043756e745961a67eff703ecd48fdf46e52f1a996aa604e4915261e1810f3f51ca2d21e0bb1a1c512883e3bc8b73e619c2e79f84d70cc9df5833c91cf7dcc8316d'
Sig: 'HOYN0sTf0A0K6r1Bxia3PVZR5ve99hUISnWgjUHdOWIdbev0O+7BVCRbufAdKGC9WVHVFe2VF45d5ezpoC800YU='
 

freetrader

Moderator
Staff member
Dec 16, 2015
2,806
6,088
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Comment: Signed by Bitcoin Armory v0.93.2


FOR BUIP002

FOR BUIP004 A1

FOR BUIP005

FOR BUIP010

FOR BUIP013 A

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----


HMxnjlKf4XF2AUXXEtAk+qZlPfvsa7kuOkxCVcxrIQPndDo3EeHXeoj7CaU9I0Ug
6HSc1o/iuzN+xB9tNLYA+9Y=
=6Yjc
-----END BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
 

cypherdoc

Well-Known Member
Aug 26, 2015
5,257
12,998
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

FOR BUIP002
FOR BUIP004 A1
FOR BUIP005
FOR BUIP010
FOR BUIP013 A
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1
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=2Wtt
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
 

solex

Moderator
Staff member
Aug 22, 2015
1,558
4,694
Voting is closed. Posting the results here after verification:

EDIT: The votes are as follows

BUIP002 17/0 passed
BUIP004 17/0 passed with A1=15 & C=2, so A1 is passed
BUIP005 15/2 passed
BUIP010 17/0 passed
BUIP013 13/2 passed with A=10 & B=3, so neither have the minimum so the Developer may proceed with what is common between A & B

Note: 43 members, 25% turnout is 11 where >=75% for/against is also required.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: cypherdoc