### VOTING IS CLOSED for BUIPs 16, 17, 18 & 19 ###

solex

Moderator
Staff member
Aug 22, 2015
1,558
4,693
Membership vote on BU Improvement Processes

One membership and three technical BUIPS listed below are open for voting.

Please reply to this thread

Votes are for/against.
Votes can be in the same message e.g. "for x,y,z" or "against a,b,c" where x,y,z etc are BUIP numbers.

Membership BUIP

BUIP019: New Members for Election #1
All are considered together i.e. "BUIP019 FOR" or "BUIP019 AGAINST"
Exceptions may be identified by using list number and +/- to include or exclude e.g. -88 +99
BUIP019 is considered as counted first so new members may vote on the technical BUIPs and these votes are counted if their membership is successful.

Technical BUIP List

BUIP016: Consensus with Classic on txn size limit
@solex

BUIP017: Datastream Compression
@Peter Tschipper

BUIP018: Bitnodes Seeding and User-Configurable DNS Seeds
@bitcartel

Votes need to be signed.


Please get involved. Bitcoin Unlimited is the start of a new paradigm where the membership decides which software changes get made to the client.

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
IKkQCRziMlyM0wC6hs6wKTIJWy7bZ4zs/Zj6jKAfjty5CctFqzwuKP6QLIX8zQn0EW8Ssibibg2Wsvc50AkRp8Y=
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peter R and Bloomie

solex

Moderator
Staff member
Aug 22, 2015
1,558
4,693
BUIP016 FOR
BUIP017 FOR
BUIP018 FOR
BUIP019 FOR

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
IF6H4TzNHEmCUd3TAy9/pIWB6jZj2rKfHbleF4e4lE7tW/R6BSB0L6GygVshlg0t+ES2hXtpk2ad+sF0GzN+Xt4=
 

cypherdoc

Well-Known Member
Aug 26, 2015
5,257
12,994
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

BUIP016 FOR
BUIP017 FOR
BUIP018 FOR
BUIP019 FOR
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1
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=9VCa
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
 

freetrader

Moderator
Staff member
Dec 16, 2015
2,806
6,088
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Comment: Signed by Bitcoin Armory v0.93.2

BUIP016 FOR
BUIP017 FOR
BUIP018 FOR
BUIP019 FOR
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----


Gy0ETb21heHv4Std/OLcYaJQq8pw0zR7EtfELpExMg8+FL6W3Lat3qNvRdlIySAs
XQMtKfYHdCDRLNnNT3UPaBs=
=/1eA
-----END BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
 

Peter Tschipper

Active Member
Jan 8, 2016
254
357
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
BUIP016 FOR
BUIP017 FOR
BUIP018 FOR
BUIP019 FOR
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----

HyqIQvI8eq5BV7fzLXnc76ZiS7jsF4DGcA7QxDkfuO5RY/HpCRAxOwqDajxmcGXX7eskuqFtuOYF9e+Vde/ZMAQ=
 

sickpig

Active Member
Aug 28, 2015
926
2,541
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
BUIP016 FOR, BUIP017 FOR, BUIP018 FOR, BUIP019 FOR
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
Hwsatk+Ml/DGeVayk1HpJ3SJdB19SDMwco/+bA+M1gPtb7m9Ytm4Gjs2q+Zy1RZvZdinCCw0XpAyGlgJQqlRKYk=

 

bitcartel

Member
Nov 19, 2015
95
93
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
BUIP016 FOR
BUIP017 FOR
BUIP018 FOR
BUIP019 FOR
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
IP/ZCrVPJQckfqO1SAkPDM+qvyUEPqbtUoJIWsvrjVzyUqvXQKDJYFNsaA/BfC3HruD4iEAuF6XztZ4Tx5iw/jk=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
 

theZerg

Moderator
Staff member
Aug 28, 2015
1,012
2,327
BUIP016 FOR
BUIP017 FOR
BUIP018 FOR
BUIP019 FOR

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
HIJltGV88kjg2KXwmQrhLENjrEz2yps8qJXbXtL/QzibP/Qn4d/YRNfeCLkLX8ZaYIOuPnuwdlBoHx+IaLro62o=
 

Peter R

Well-Known Member
Aug 28, 2015
1,398
5,595
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
BUIP016 FOR
BUIP017 FOR
BUIP018 FOR
BUIP019 FOR
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
1BWZe6XkGLcf6DWC3TFXiEtZmcyAoNq5BW
IH7ZITV13d8+j5KKTiRvA9sdmM764s/sOOIzW9ii8c4r4zhkWPuln3pEsOk5Iro6XhYagLPY0MDbRCSFRSr+9HM=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
 

Lee Adams

Member
Dec 23, 2015
89
74
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----

BUIP016 FOR
BUIP017 FOR
BUIP018 FOR
BUIP019 FOR
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
Version: Bitcoin-qt (1.0)
Address: 1ruQ2wceuMt83aXQsERyWGxQawHqXERSd

ICiD6PFnGnurw5VUWV3fIJsUjT/93dsLOTOwv13dVRRRKvqz388GyHwpX+6J/FldDAmEuhhze2TSF3/UDTZc/mI=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
 

lunar

Well-Known Member
Aug 28, 2015
1,001
4,290
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----

BUIP016 FOR
BUIP017 FOR
BUIP018 FOR
BUIP019 FOR

-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----

1BpYYT2HQzQdz5CFPM1nehCZd1xWPtNbma

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
HzfLRe5t0lE6xl495Uldvhsw6EXCBJiHBt4Y4LXT4y07esb/dNYVzQjVcwWFPADGKwhbyPXXgwQemOGIm2Klhio=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNATURE-----
 

YarkoL

Active Member
Dec 18, 2015
176
258
Tuusula
yarkol.github.io
yarko@spacedandy ~/BitcoinUnlimited/src $ ./bitcoin-cli signmessage 1QJRHKrZs9V6XVeM9hAaB6jv9JYFvLLSox "BUIP016 FOR, BUIP017 FOR, BUIP018 FOR, BUIP019 FOR"
IKJzMCryhv30k6gYvsqCI6FfBxeY04ChybXdSZFOezwWEquTUYSxEzLcRarwQGlmImhEMNT55OZ67NbxJo20QZM=
 

awemany

Well-Known Member
Aug 19, 2015
1,387
5,054
BUIP016 FOR
BUIP019 FOR

awemany, may 4th 2016

IBZDlkNic7vz5gpFDklYAdk8J4Xvb2qrLtkud+gaURCINxd/5g66d+WBTBn1ulDpfCdD6cKabUD/CGJXVgJXToc=
 

Bagatell

Active Member
Aug 28, 2015
728
1,191
BUIP016 FOR
BUIP017 FOR
BUIP018 FOR
BUIP019 FOR

IJ9ZUtuH2Egprz9/7Q7sPsaeAMheV1YdClqNZb+jWY0+MsIwc4KyJ5v7xIXZiHZ6d9ehLd8ziQQEtj7/442fMZU=
 
  • Like
Reactions: solex

awemany

Well-Known Member
Aug 19, 2015
1,387
5,054
I didn't vote on BUIP017 yet (due to the license worry). Here it is:

---
BUIP017 FOR

awemany, may 6th 2016

II0SZPpkMIjKoXxECfrLQUGfKirXf+Qa6H8LlAE1k+6ZYmXPx2dChE4Pd1jKhJbqff32cyR8RGwTDMp1V6WmTfQ=
 

solex

Moderator
Staff member
Aug 22, 2015
1,558
4,693
Marking the vote closed. Thanks to those who participated.
Posting the results here shortly.

EDIT: The votes are as follows

BUIP019 14/0 passed
Note: 43 members, 25% turnout is 11 of which >=75% for/against is also required

BUIP016 14/0 passed
BUIP017 14/0 passed
BUIP018 13/0 passed
Note: 48 members, 25% turnout is 12 of which >=75% for/against is also required

(including 1 vote pending signature)

-----------------------
edit (member count 49 not 48, result unchanged)
 
Last edited: